Your Host, Rick Bayan
What Is Cynicism?
How To Know If You're A Cynic
714 Things To Be Cynical About
What Are You Cynical About?
Cynic's Message Board
Rick's Notebook
Cynic's Dictionary Sampler
Order The Cynic's Dictionary
Cynic's Hall Of Fame
Other Sites For Cynics
Cynic's Mailbag
Spread The Word!

Rick's Notebook

Profile of the author
Monthly tirades
Archive of weekly columns

"Some Cynical Guy" No. 65: March 1, 2002

Bullies With Social Skills

Among the torments and indignities of adolescence, none creates more misery than being the object of a bully’s scorn. And the worst form of bullying -- even more painful than the fist of an oversize lummox upside the nose -- is SOCIAL bullying at the hands of the head baboons. A black eye will heal within days; a social snub can hurt forever. To suffer the rude rebuffs of a self-appointed tribal dictator is a fate worse than a bad report card or being spotted at the mall in the company of one’s parents. And it probably causes more long-term scars than a faceful of zits.

We tend to think of bullying as a primarily masculine form of recreation, a plague of alpha males and their oafish cohorts descending upon the weak of limb and the meek of spirit. With the ruthlessness of gods and hunters, they cull the unfit from their herd by bludgeoning them into submission, physically or emotionally. To be called a fag or a weenie in public is tantamount to being branded with a scarlet letter.

But now the official thinking has begun to recognize that bullying is an equal-opportunity oppressor: it turns out that girls can be just as wantonly cruel to each other as boys. Girls, of course, have known this all along, but it always helps to get a little scholarly corroboration from the experts. While boy-bullies use fists and crudity to nail sissies and other designated rejects, girl-bullies apparently employ their superior social wiles to lacerate their victims. Boy-bullies tend to be more beef than brain; at least the bloody-nosed victims can secretly snicker at the doltishness of their oppressors. A girl doesn’t have it so easy: she’s up against an even more malevolent foe. Far from being a dreamy world of slumber parties, fuzzy stuffed critters and giggly friendships that last for decades, the life of a pubescent girl seems to be, if anything, even more nasty and brutish than those of her geeky male counterparts. Girl-bullies are nothing less than junior-miss Byzantine empresses plotting in secrecy to blind and maim their rivals. They’re bullies with social skills.

A recent New York Times article cited the work of Rosalind Wiseman, who has studied the social depredations of middle-school girls and currently runs a class aimed at persuading them to be nicer. Wiseman has observed the cliques, gossip, barbs and ostracisms first-hand; she has witnessed the unapologetic cruelty of the ‘queen bees’ and the wounds of their lower-status sting victims. She has seen newly enthroned queen bees instantly shed their old friends like yesterday’s press-on nails.

Everyone at the north end of the female hierarchy seems to accept this arrangement with unblinking eyelashes. Girls who know nothing of Darwin, pecking orders or natural selection can discuss the merciless social mechanics of their tribe with frightening astuteness: the accepted ones are winning because they’re winners, the rejected ones are losing because they’re losers, and all’s right with the world. A newly accepted queen bee who dumps an old friend is inflicting a fatal sting -- social death-blow -- and she knows it. Yet she seems to be no more apologetic than a vampire on its first night-stalk.

The bitten one suffers the pain of having been savaged by a former confidante, snubbed and rejected in a public and terminally humiliating fashion. Meanwhile, the new insider finds that she must adapt to a rigid and frequently ridiculous code of conformity -- wearing certain outfits on designated days of the week, for example. After all, social success is a function of one’s ability to master the codes -- so you might as well start learning in middle school. The social codes will prove to be a lot more useful in later life than reading about plate tectonics or the Teapot Dome Scandal.

How is it, I wonder, that certain favored individuals set themselves up as the arbiters of adolescent social fitness? Who gives them an authority exceeding that of teachers and even guidance counselors? How is it that their judgments reverberate throughout the tribe, so that the individuals singled out for rejection by the generalissimo are automatically snubbed by the inner circle of colonels and lieutenants? Both the bullies and the bullied -- male and female alike -- know that there’s more to this game than deciding who gets to be invited to the in-crowd’s Saturday night parties. The social arbiters are, in effect, deciding who deserves to reproduce with the most desirable specimens of their generation. The in-crowders of both sexes are culling their ranks, rejecting those with odd genetic traits: out go all the long noses, buck teeth, jerky hand-gestures and poetic sensibilities. The insiders generally reject raw brilliance along with hopeless ineptitude.

If the bullies’ efforts succeed, their victims never again take themselves seriously as participants in the great evolutionary footrace. Having lost the last tatters of their sexual self-esteem, they resign themselves to lives of studious celibacy: Saturday nights spent in the company of their geeky celibate friends, technically smart but hopeless in combat. Or, unable to stand the abuse any longer, they might lash back in a red-eyed frenzy of gunfire. Either way, they don’t get to reproduce with the cheerleaders and student council officers.

The ripples from adolescent rejection continue to spread outward through our souls for decades to come. Those ripples tell us where we stand in the great social pecking order, how good we feel when we look into the mirror and, ultimately, which potential mates are beyond our reach. The bespectacled nerd who goes on to M.I.T. despite the taunting of his alpha classmates will end up with a more distinguished career than most of them. But I wonder if the nerd unconsciously shies away from members of the opposite sex who seem too formidable, too socially graced, too comfortable among the insiders.

How skillfully the insiders of both sexes have played their game! And thus the weakest genes -- or at least the weakest as perceived by the hardiest and least sensitive souls -- are eliminated from contention, leaving the jocks and go-getters to mate with the queen bees. Together they produce offspring with the requisite combination of looks, brashness and middling intelligence: in short, future in-crowders. Thus the bullying of dominant males and queen bees ensures that the next generation of in-crowders won’t be overrun with math wonks and palefaced artists. It will look pretty much like their own crowd: good hair, good teeth, lots of pep -- solid breeding stock all the way.

Cynic’s Pick of the Week

Last week’s 44th annual Grammy Awards telecast earned the lowest ratings since 1995. Maybe it had something to do with the nattering lecture about the evils of downloading music from the Internet. Or could it just be that NOBODY IS WRITING MEMORABLE SONGS ANYMORE?

© 2002 by Bridget Petrella Media Relations. "Some Cynical Guy" appears here by permission of the publisher. If you'd like this column to appear regularly in  your own site or publication, write to UPBEATmag@aol.com.

"Some Cynical Guy" column archive:
2002
81 -- A Brisk Walk Through the Ruins
80 -- The Fountain of Futility
79 -- Farewell to the Big House
78 -- The Cynical Guy Contemplates Cell Phones
77 -- Rich and Poor in Paradise
76 -- Dead Ducks: A Tale of the Food Chain
75 -- Old Comedians Just Fade Away
74 -- Suburbia Comes to Manayunk
73 -- When Nestlings Won't Leave the Nest
72 -- The Curse of High Standards
71 -- Inside the House of Horrors
70 -- The Post-Yuppie Handbook
69 -- Spring Reflections
68 -- Priestly Perversions
67 -- British Teeth: An Apology
66 -- The Sniffling Snout
65 -- Bullies with Social Skills
64 -- Supermarket Rage
63 -- Is the U.S. Really the Greatest?
62 -- The Holes in Our Armor
61 -- A Breath of Used Air
60 -- The Cynical Guy Has Sex
59 -- Let's Abolish the Seven-Day Week!
2001
58 -- Why Worry About the Future of Books?
57 -- The Friendly Face of Evil
56 -- Why We Live Where We Live
55 -- The Cynical Guy Discovers Talk Radio
54 -- Kite-Flying and Other Crimes
53 -- My Night as a Socialite
52 -- Gardening Is Not for Sissies
51 -- Invaders of the Honeysuckle
50 -- To Be a Cat
49 -- The Upside of Terrorism
48 -- The Vanishing Nerd
47 -- Anger Management for Cynics
46 -- Let's Level the Playing Field for Disadvantaged WASPs
45 -- First Impressions, Lasting Impressions
44 -- Close Encounter with a Go-Getter
43 -- Cheering for a Perennial Loser
42 -- The Cynical Guy Reads the Tabloids
41 -- When Does the Good Part Begin?
40 -- Confessions of an Internet Addict
39 -- The Decline of Punctuation and Civilization
38 -- Oh Baby, What a Nightmare!
37 -- The Cynical Guy Watches 'Xena: Warrior Princess'
36 -- A Night-Stroll into the Void
35 -- In Search of the Elusive Wild Tomato
34 -- Getting in Touch with Your Inner S.O.B.
33 -- The Lure of the Lurid
32 -- Black Tie and Beard Stubble
31 -- In Heaven There Is No Pez
30 -- Did You Make the Forbes Celebrity 100 List?
29 -- Redesigning Mt. Rushmore
28 -- On Listening to Dead Voices
27 -- Selling Your Soul on eBay
26 -- Sympathy for Colonel Klink
25 -- Democratic Celebrities in Exile
24 -- High School Revisited
23 -- A Farewell to Bachelorhood
2000
22 -- Requiem for a Middleweight
21 -- Is There a Gene for Tackiness?
20 -- How the Beautiful People Entertain Themselves
19 -- The Cynical Guy Gets Behind the Wheel
18 -- The Fickle Finger of Fame
17 -- Adventures in Bodybuilding
16 -- Some Don't Like It Hot
15 -- The Cynical Guy Watches Oprah
14 -- Sports Parents: Menace to Society?
13 -- Airfare Is No Fair at All
12 -- There's No Such Thing as 'New and Improved'
11 -- Celtomania!
10 -- The Naked Pate
9 -- Vanishing Act
8 -- Bush vs. Gore: It Could Be Worse
7 -- Who Wants to Be a Survivor?
6 -- Adventures in Heart Attack Prevention
5 -- Where Men Are Men
4 -- Thoughts While Listening to the Car Radio
3 -- History Is HISTORY
2 -- The Great Casino
1 -- Greetings from Your New Cynical Guy



Profile of a Cynic...

Photo of Rick Bayan

Rick Bayan was born and raised in New Brunswick, New Jersey, where he enjoyed an idyllic suburban childhood—the perfect background for a lifetime of cynical disillusionment.  He has held a number of typical jobs for an idealistic liberal arts graduate, including assistant editor of Rubber Age and managing editor of Container News.  At Time-Life Books he was assigned to write about plumbing fixtures.  His work as copy chief for Day-Timers, Inc., won six advertising awards, none of which dampened his cheerfully morose view of business and life.  He has written three books, including Words That Sell and The Cynic's Dictionary, and tons of junk mail.

Bayan, who claims to be a "kinder, gentler cynic," lives with his wife in a 100-year-old former livery stable in Philadelphia. His weekly column, "Some Cynical Guy," is published and syndicated by Upbeat Online. 

 

 

site design by:
<IMG SRC="lowf-logo.gif" WIDTH=151 HEIGHT=51 BORDER=0>